For many forex investors, there are essentially only two types of forex trading platforms: one where the trader deals directly with the forex broker as the counterparty,and the other is where the forex broker routes orders to the market, with the broker not assuming any forex risk. However, in actual trading, the second type of platform can be further divided into STP and A-BOOK,and while the vast majority of investors do not understand this distinction, many forex brokers frequently confuse the two.
In fact, while forex brokers use liquidity providers (LPs) for hedging in both STP and A-BOOK trading, there are significant differences in the operational details. So, specifically, what types of trading do these two terms refer to, and what are the differences between them?
STP (Straight Through Processing) can be simply understood as “hedging first, then executing the order.” In other words, after an investor places an order on the platform, the forex broker first hedges the position with a liquidity provider and then executes the trade with the investor on the platform. In contrast, A-BOOK involves executing the order first and then hedging. That is, the forex platform first executes the trade between the traders on the platform and then hedges with the liquidity provider.
These two trading models appear to yield the same results—with only the order of the trades reversed—but in reality, this is not the case. Veteran forex traders know that the final price of each trade may differ from the initial quote; this phenomenon is known as slippage.
Why does slippage occur? It’s because the foreign exchange market is highly volatile, with prices fluctuating virtually every moment. If a forex trade is held for too long, it is highly likely that slippage will occur.
However, when slippage occurs, STP and A-BOOK differ in terms of who bears the risk. With STP, the platform first hedges with an LP, so the platform itself does not experience slippage because the trade is executed almost instantaneously. For investors, however, completing a trade requires first submitting a quote to the platform,the platform must first hedge with the liquidity provider before executing the investor’s order. Since the transaction takes longer, slippage is highly likely, potentially resulting in losses. With an A-Book model, the risk of slippage is reversed: the platform bears the risk. The investor first completes the trade with the platform, which then hedges the position and absorbs any unexpected losses.
So some people might wonder: Since STP doesn’t expose the platform to the risk of slippage, why do some platforms still use A-BOOK for their trading operations and willingly bear the losses from slippage?
This is because the A-BOOK model provides a better trading experience for platform investors. When using the A-BOOK trading model, investors simply execute trades at the quoted price, and the trade is completed almost instantly—eliminating the need to spend excessive time waiting to see if the trade will encounter unexpected issues or even be canceled by the platform.
Generally speaking, the larger the investor, the more important this certainty is for their trades; therefore, many high-quality clients tend to use trading platforms that offer the A-BOOK trading model to execute their trades.
Let us help you build the perfect forex brokerage firm! Build your forex business using our cutting-edge technology. LXSuite provides everything you need to build a brokerage business from the ground up. Choosing our reliable and comprehensive software solutions allows you to focus on doing what you do best. Offer your clients the world’s most popular forex trading platforms through our MT4/MT5 white-label solutions, using either your own brand or ours.
